Leave this website quickly.

About The Promise Scotland's Directors

The Promise Scotland has a Board of Directors. With their wide range of knowledge and experience – including lived experience of care – they are well placed to help The Promise Scotland in driving change.

Their direction will help The Promise Scotland in its support of others, helping make sure that Scotland keeps the promise.

The Board of Directors isn't The Oversight Board

The Board of Directors isn’t the same thing as The Promise Oversight Board.

The Promise Oversight Board exists to check up on how all of Scotland is keeping the promise. It’s not a part of The Promise Scotland, which is a distinct organisation.

And it’s this organisation which the Board of Directors is in charge of. It acts to make decisions that mean The Promise Scotland will do its job as best as it can, rather than checking if all Scotland is keeping the promise.

Minutes of meetings

Minutes for the ninth meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the first meeting of the Audit Risk Committee.

Minutes for the eighth meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the first meeting of the Finance Committee.

Minutes for the seventh meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the sixth meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the fifth meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the fourth meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the third meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the second meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Minutes for the initial meeting of The Promise Scotland's Directors.

Chief Executive Officer

Fraser McKinlay - Chief Executive Officer
Photo credit: Sarah Maclean

Fraser McKinlay

Chief Executive Officer

Fraser McKinlay is the Chief Executive Officer of The Promise Scotland and sits on the Board of Directors.

He spent 16 years working for Audit Scotland, including ten years as Controller of Audit and Director of Performance Audit and Best Value (PABV). He has been running his own consulting business since April 2021.

As Controller of Audit (CoA), Fraser reported to the Accounts Commission on all matters relating to the audit of local authorities in Scotland. In his ten years as CoA, he produced over 60 Best Value audit reports across all local authorities, alongside many other statutory reports.

As Director of PABV, Fraser was responsible for performance audit across all sectors of public services in Scotland. This work focused on:

  • governance,
  • financial sustainability, and
  • value for money.

Before joining Audit Scotland, Fraser was a public services consultant with Eglinton in Edinburgh and KPMG in London. He specialised in leadership, change management, facilitation and process improvement.

Since starting his own business, he has worked with a range of clients in the public and third sectors, specialising in:

  • strategy,
  • leadership, and
  • change.

He is particularly interested in systems change, and how we use public money more effectively to deliver improved outcomes for citizens, families, and communities.

In October 2021, Scottish Ministers appointed him as a member of the Independent Oversight and Assurance Group for Mental Health Services in Tayside.

Fraser holds:

  • a Postgraduate Diploma (with Distinction) in Strategic Leadership from Warwick Business School, and
  • a degree in Industrial Relations from the University of Strathclyde.

He is a member of the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development.


Fiona Duncan - Chair
Photo credit: Sarah Maclean

Fiona Duncan


Fiona Duncan is Chair of The Promise Scotland, the organisation responsible for driving and supporting the change demanded by the conclusions of the Independent Care Review— which Fiona also chaired.

Directors of The Promise Scotland

Anna Black

Anna Black

Anna Black is a locum GP in Glasgow, working between:

  • Dungavel Immigration Detention Centre,
  • St Vincent’s Hospice, and
  • practices in Possilpark and Pollokshields.

She also works in the Glasgow Youth Health Service, with a focus on mental and sexual health. She is passionate about reducing health inequalities and improving access to healthcare.

She also regularly teaches at the University of Glasgow, and through NHS Education Scotland’s programme for training for GPs and GP trainees. In her teaching, she covers:

  • migration health,
  • inclusion health, and
  • health inequalities.

Anna is also:

David Garbutt

David Garbutt

David Garbutt has held many policing roles, including:

  • Chief Officer of Lothian and Borders Police,
  • Chief Officer of Grampian Police,
  • Assistant Inspector of Constabulary,
  • Director of the Scottish Police College. and

He was awarded the Queen’s Police Medal in the 2001 New Year Honours.

He has also been a member of:

  • the Board of the Scottish Leadership Foundation, and
  • the Justice Sector Skills Council.

And has chaired:

He currently chairs the NHS National Performance Management Committee, and is a member of:

  • the Everyone Matters Implementation Group, and
  • the National Leadership Development Programme Board.
Jackie Brock

Jackie Brock

Jackie Brock was previously a Deputy Director within Scottish Government, and Chief Executive of Children in Scotland. She acted as The Promise Scotland Interim Chief Operating Officer supporting the set-up of the organisation.

Jim Savege

Jim Savege

Jim Savege started his career training as a teacher in Liverpool, before working in management consultancy. His career in local government spans nearly two decades ,with previous roles at:

  • Staffordshire County Council, and
  • Cumbria County Council.

Jim took up post as Chief Executive with Aberdeenshire Council in February 2015. He is:

  • Returning Officer for Aberdeenshire Council, and
  • Clerk to the Lieutenancy of Aberdeenshire.

He is Chair of the Scottish Resilience Partnership, and a past Chair of Solace Scotland, continuing to work across public services locally and nationally to ensure the most effective team approach. He's passionate about working with communities to help people achieve their dreams.

Philip Rycroft

Philip Rycroft

Philip Rycroft was a civil servant for 30 years, in roles including those in education and children and young people's policy.

He worked for 20 years in the Scottish Office, then Executive and Government.

For the last 10 years of his career, he worked in Whitehall, latterly:

  • as head of the UK Governance Group in the Cabinet Office, with responsibility for advising ministers on all aspects of the constitution and devolution, and
  • as the Permanent Secretary of the Department for Exiting the EU.

He is now a non-executive director, academic and consultant.

Sally Loudon

Sally Loudon

Sally Loudon was appointed Chief Executive of COSLA in January 2016. She took up this role having been Chief Executive at Argyll and Bute Council since September 2008.

She has also held key office-bearer positions within:

Sally has over 20 years’ local government experience, having worked in senior roles in a number of local authorities, including:

  • East Lothian Council, and
  • Midlothian Council.

She is a champion of the role councils can play in community leadership.

Victoria Underwood

Victoria Underwood

Vicky Underwood is Head of Leadership, Governance and Research at the College Development Network (CDN).

A key focus of her work is driving forward enhancement within colleges. In this way, she supports them to deliver for learners, their families and communities. She is passionate about the role colleges – and the wider education system – play in addressing poverty.

Before joining CDN, Vicky worked in several roles in the UK and around the world, delivering projects in:

  • international education,
  • business development, and
  • policy.

She comes from a large family which includes care experienced young people, and they have had a profound impact on her personal and professional life. She's passionately committed to playing her part in helping Scotland keep the promise.