Comment on the Care Inspectorate and Mental Welfare Commission report: The journey to trauma-informed restrictive practice in Scotland’s secure accommodation services
Commenting on the Care Inspectorate and Mental Welfare Commission report which was released today, Fraser McKinlay, Chief Executive at The Promise Scotland, said:
Scotland has promised to strive to become a nation that does not restrain its children. The Independent Care Review heard from children that restraint can be frightening, painful and embarrassing. Yet this report tells us that 79% of children spoken to in secure care settings said they had been restrained and the same number said they had been secluded.
The way in which some children have normalised their experiences, talking of their ‘preferred’ way to be restrained, is particularly shocking and shows how far Scotland has to go to make the promise a reality.
The report also shows there are inconsistencies and variations across training, reporting and outcomes.
The rights of children and young people are not always adequately upheld when they are in secure care and the workforce who care for them are not always supported in the ways required.
This is in spite of solutions to many of the issues raised in the report being previously identified through reports and reviews, including the Independent Care Review and the ‘Reimagining Secure Care’ report. In particular, many of the issues raised will be improved by making significant changes to the current secure care operating model.
The Promise Scotland, along with the Children’s Commissioner for Scotland, Equality and Human Rights Commission and Scottish Human Rights Commission, have repeatedly called for a coherent definition of restraint and consistent monitoring, recording and reporting processes across all settings, including in secure care. This work needs to happen, and urgently.
We know there are good people working hard in secure care across Scotland. The report finds that a large majority of young people surveyed felt safe, cared for and treated with respect.
But, this report also makes clear – once again – that more must be done, urgently, to ensure children and young people understand their rights, have access to the information and relationships they need to be heard, and are kept safe.
In the next few weeks, the latest data on restraint across a wider range of care settings will be published, which will provide further evidence on what is happening across Scotland. It is incumbent on everyone with responsibility for looking after Scotland’s children to work together, and to act on what it says.
Read the report on the Care Inspectorate's website.
About the author
Fraser McKinlay
Chief Executive
Fraser has been Chief Executive of The Promise Scotland since September 2022. Prior to that, he spent 16 years working for Audit Scotland, including ten years as Controller of Audit and Director of Performance Audit and Best Value.
Before joining Audit Scotland, Fraser was a public services consultant in Edinburgh and London. He specialised in leadership, change management, facilitation and process improvement.
Fraser is committed to systems change, focusing on how public money is spent more effectively to enable better lives for children, young people, care experienced adults, families, and communities.